Recommended Measurements for Scaling Soil Health Assessment

Overview

Healthy soil is the foundation for regenerative, climate-smart agriculture. Measuring management-induced changes in soil health can provide insight into farmers’ progress at establishing more regenerative systems and guide place-based selection of practice changes that promote enhanced ecosystem processes and services.

To identify effective and widely applicable measurements of soil health, the Soil Health Institute (SHI) conducted a 3-year, $6.5-million project that evaluated over 30 soil health indicators at 124 long-term agricultural research sites across North America where conventional systems were compared with regenerative soil health systems. Sites were selected to enable statistical assessment of each soil measurement across a continental range in climates, soils, cropping systems, and management practices to identify a minimal suite of measurements that are cost-effective, interpretable, and responsive to soil health promoting practices.

Based on these results, SHI recommends three measurements to be widely applied across North America (and likely beyond). Those measurements include:

  1. soil organic carbon concentration
  2. carbon mineralization potential
  3. aggregate stability
Measurement Method Reflected Outcome
Organic Carbon Concentration Dry combustion. For calcareous soil: Total C – Inorganic C
  • Nutrient cycling and retention
  • Stable and distinct soil structure
  • Available water holding capacity
Carbon Mineralization Potential 24-hr CO2 burst resulting from rewetting air dried, sieved soil
  • Carbon and nutrient cycling capacity
  • Strongly related to microbial biomass and activity
Aggregate Stability 10-min change in slaking via image analysis
  • Resistance to wind and water erosion
  • Soil water infiltration and storage
  • Stable soil structure

While these three metrics provide a minimum suite of widely applicable measurements for assessing soil health, additional measurements may be included depending on the landowner’s or researcher’s objectives. For example, adding soil texture to this list of measurements allows us to calculate a soil’s available water holding capacity. We can then show a farmer how much more water they can store by increasing their organic carbon and improving soil health. Because management does not change soil texture (sand, silt, and clay), it only needs to be measured once.

Together, these three indicators and predicted available water holding capacity can inform stakeholders on how soil health management practices affect soil’s ability to support biomass production; store, filter, and transform nutrients and water; host biodiversity; and regulate C pools. This minimal suite of soil health indicators is expected to increase the number of stakeholders capable of quantitatively testing and monitoring their soil, which in turn may increase adoption of management practices that result in healthier soils.

Learn more about our recommended measurements for scaling soil health.

Highlights of the North American Project to Evaluate Soil Health Measurements

30+

Soil health indicators assessed

124

Research sites in the study

20+

Peer-reviewed papers using SHI measurement data

Resources

Peer-Reviewed Publications from SHI

Peer-reviewed publications detailing our research efforts to identify a minimum suite of recommended measurements are linked below along with brief interpretive summaries that distill the key findings from each study.

Publications Using SHI Data

Papers drawing on data from the North American Project to Evaluate Soil Health Measurements.

  • Microbial Proxies for Anoxic Microsites Vary with Management and Partially Explain Soil Carbon Concentration

  • Assessment of soil health and identification of key soil health indicators for five long-term crop rotations with varying fertility management

  • Pedotransfer Functions for Field Capacity, Permanent Wilting Point, and Available Water Capacity Based on Random Forest Models for Routine Soil Health Analysis

  • Cross-correlating soil aggregate stability methods to facilitate universal interpretation

  • Diffuse reflectance mid-infrared spectroscopy is viable without fine milling

  • Long-term manure application improves soil health and stabilizes carbon in continuous maize production system

  • Evaluating common soil health tests for dryland wheat systems of inland Pacific Northwest

  • Long-term agro-management strategies shape soil bacterial community structure in dryland wheat systems

  • Maximizing soil organic carbon stocks under cover cropping: insights from long-term agricultural experiments in North America

  • The story of long-term research sites and soil health in Canadian agriculture

  • Relating soil physical properties to other soil properties and crop yields

  • Relating soil chemical properties to other soil properties and dryland crop production

  • Autoclaved citrate-extractable protein as a soil health indicator relates to soil properties and crop production

  • How soil carbon fractions relate to soil properties and crop yields in dryland cropping systems?

  • Enzyme activities as soil health indicators in relation to soil characteristics and crop production

  • Relationship between soil carbon and nitrogen, soil properties, and dryland crop yields

  • Soil health indicators and crop yield in response to long-term cropping sequence and nitrogen fertilization

  • Carbon dioxide flush as a soil health indicator related to soil properties and crop yields

  • Soil health indicators and crop yield in a long-term cropping system experiment

Standard Measurement Methods

Here we share laboratory SOPs (Standard Operation Procedures) that SHI uses to communicate needs with commercial soil testing labs.

  • Soil Health Sampling Standard Operating Procedure

  • Soil Total Carbon and Nitrogen by Dry Combustion Standard Operating Procedure

  • Soil Inorganic Carbon by Modified Pressure Calcimeter

  • Potential Carbon Mineralization Standard Operating Procedure

  • Particle Size Analysis by Hydrometer Standard Operating Procedure

  • Aggregate Stability via Slaking Image Analysis: Multi-Sample Image Acquisition Standard Operating Procedure

  • Predicting Available Water Holding Capacity

  • Measuring Soil Health at Scale: Recommended Methods for Laboratory Analyses

Additional Resources



Funders